Cheap Varistors or Expensive TVS-diodes?

Vladimir Gurevich

Abstract


Varistors and suppressors (TVS-diodes) are well-known and widely-used in electronic equipment as components providing voltage surge protection. For very powerful but very short-lasting pulses of the nanosecond range, with steep raising edge (such as HEMP pulses), the suitability of varistors and TVS-diodes is questionable. Since the technical community did not reach any shared vision regarding this point, the author performed its own tests described below.  


Keywords


varistort; TVS-diode; supressor; HEMP; EMP

Full Text:

PDF

References


Protection Technology Comparison Chart. – Protek Devices, 2013.

TND335/D. Transient Overvoltage Protection, ON Semiconductor, Semiconductor Components Industries, LLC, 2008

Electronics, protection against overvoltages. Paragraph Н. 51. Basics of overvoltage protection. – Weidmuller.

AN 1826/0104. Transient Protection Solution: Transil™ diode versus Varistor /Bremond A., Karoui C. – STMicroelectronics.

S. J. Goldman, Selecting Protection Devices: TVS Diodes vs. Metal-Oxide Varistors, Power Electronics, June 1, 2010.

Han S. M., Huh C. S., Choi J. S. A Validation of Conventional Protection Devices in Protecting EMP Threats. – Progress in Electromagnetic Research, 2011, Vol. 119, pp. 253 – 263.

Howell T. Comparing Circuit Protection Technologies for 48 V DC in High Surge Environments. – Protection Engineers Group Conference, Dallas, March 14 – 16, 2017.

Gurevich V. The Problem of Correct Choice of Ferrite Beads – Electrical Engineering & Electromechanics, 2016. No. 2, pp. 71- 75.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.22385/jctecs.v18i0.268